2 Tishrei 5787/September 13, 2026
Hazal, the great Torah commentators of the Talmudic period and beyond, suggest that God was testing our ancestor Abraham to confirm the nature -- and the limits -- of his faith.
Søren Kierkegaard described Abraham ready to execute his son as a “knight of faith,” a man willing to let Divine command overrule the love and commitments of care and protection that bind parents to children, and humans to one another.
Jewish triumphalists have argued that the Binding of Isaac is both proof text and warning. We, the Jewish people, are not like the other nations -- not like the worshippers of Baal or the peoples of Carthage -- who sacrificed their children as part of their cults and sacred practice.
The British poet Wilfred Owen used the Akeda as the template for the trench warfare of WWI when he wrote in the Parable of the Old Man and the Young
When lo! an angel called him out of heaven,
Saying, Lay not thy hand upon the lad,
Neither do anything to him. Behold,
A ram, caught in a thicket by its horns;
Offer the Ram of Pride instead of him.
But the old man would not so, but slew his son,
And half the seed of Europe, one by one.
Leonard Cohen transformed text he knew from his Montreal childhood when, in the midst of the Vietnam war, he sang
You who build these altars now
to sacrifice these children,
you must not do it anymore.
We read the Akeda, the story of the Binding of Isaac, every Rosh Hashanah. We review the story, in all of its familiarity, at a moment in the year when we are paying exquisite attention.
The year has already begun. We have a chance to begin again. We have a choice to be the people we long to be.
I stand in awe and humility before generations of Akedah commentators.
But this year, for the first time, I approached the story of the Binding of Isaac from a different vantage point, one I had never previously considered.
Abraham was the father of Isaac. But he never stopped being the son of Terah.
Abraham’s father Terah was not just a worshipper of idols: he was a god-maker.
Midrash says that Terah crafted them of wood and stone, in a series that represented the circuit of the zodiac, feeding and paying homage to each idol in turn.
Psalm 115 notes, dismissively, that these figurines, the work of human hands “have mouths, but cannot speak, eyes, but cannot see; they have ears, but cannot hear, noses, but cannot smell; they have hands, but cannot touch, feet, but cannot walk; they can make no sound in their throats.
Those who fashion them, all who trust in them, shall become like them.”
That is, the person who believes in the power of idols will become inert, a person without the ability to communicate, without personal agency.
The apocryphal book of Jubilees, written in the 2nd century BCE, elaborates Terah’s backstory.
Abraham encourages his father not to worship idols, which mislead people about the nature of holiness. Instead, he urges his father to worship the God of heaven, the one who causes the rain and dew to descend on the earth, the God who created everything by Divine Word.
In Jubilees -- and this must have been a story that was circulating at the time -- Terah admits he knows the idols are worthless -- but if he tells the truth about them, the gullible community of people who worship them will kill him. At times like these, it’s better to keep your mouth shut.
If the book of Jubilees has it right, piety is submission and social opprobrium compels silence.
Abraham destroys his father’s idols, like a child smashing a room full of toys, and feeds them to the fire. If you learned this story as a child in Hebrew school, like I did, you could be allowed a frisson of delight. There is something delicious about being a powerless child trashing something your parents treasure.
And in a twist unique to the story of young Abraham, you get rewarded for your transgression -by becoming the first Jewish person in human history!
Yet. I glimpse in Abraham’s formative experiences a direct, if hidden, line to the Akeda.
In Genesis 22, God calls “Abraham”-- the private name between the two of them, the name Abraham has exchanged for his birth name -- and Abraham answers Hineni, “Here I am.”
He is being told, again, to leave and go to a new place. This time the destination is the hillside of Moriah. And there, the Divine commands, he must sacrifice his son Isaac as a burnt offering.
Abraham listens to the voice he has understood as Divine authority. He has plenty of time to think about what he is going to do. Plenty of time to argue, as he did to protect the residents of Sodom and Gomorrah. Plenty of time to turn back.
He doesn’t argue. He doesn’t turn back.
Does he feel he has personal agency in the face of Divine command?
You know the story. The donkey, the wood, the fire, the ram, and Abraham’s readiness to sacrifice his son, because God’s voice told him to do so.
Some commentators say that Abraham didn’t kill Isaac, but that the time on the mountain destroyed their relationship. They would never speak again.
That his mother Sarah’s death, in the next chapter of Torah, is a direct result of the shock she experienced when she learned what Abraham was prepared to do.
But no matter how much his own journey of devotion and identity diverges from his upbringing in Ur of the Chaldees, Abraham remains Terah’s son.
This is a man capable of submission in the face of authority.
This is a man capable of violence, of destroying the most precious things in the world.
As far as he knows, he has already sentenced his son Ishmael and Ishmael’s mother Hagar to a painful death in the wilderness. God told him to listen to Sarah, that Ishmael would be a father of nations, too. But when summoned to sacrifice Isaac, the command is to sacrifice
אֶת־יְחִֽידְךָ֤ אֲשֶׁר־אָהַ֙בְתָּ֙ his only son, the one he loves. Doesn’t that mean that Ishmael is gone?
And now this.
Abraham gave up everything once before, when he left his father’s home. He does not act surprised when he is asked to give up everything again.
Maybe those promises God made about his becoming the father of nations aren’t all that solid.
And maybe, just maybe, Abraham thinks that he deserves to lose his sons: first Ishmael and now Isaac. Maybe, just maybe, losing his sons, his descendants, is payback for his repudiation and destruction of his father’s world.
The Binding of Isaac asks us, as individuals and as a community, whose legacy we are carrying forward, and whose voice we believe we are hearing.
Whose legacy we are carrying forward and whose voice we believe we are hearing.
And then to choose.
May each of us be written in the book of life, for goodness and for peace.
RSS Feed